Subscribe to this blog in Radio:
Didn't find what you were looking for?
E-mail this blog's author, Bruce Umbaugh: 
|
|
 |
Tuesday, February 25, 2003 |
Adam Curry pointed at A music industry case study, in the New York Daily News. Imagine a new, hot band -- capable of leveraging a higher royalty rate than typical for new acts -- with a gold-record debut album. (We're told that only 128 of more than 30,000 records reached that level in 2002.) That record would gross $8,490,000. Work the numbers. The four guys in the band end up making
about the same as a city sanitation worker with two years' experience, without health benefits, vacation and retirement fund. But with, of course, groupies.
11:00:37 AM
|
|
Following on yesterday's story about his speech at Duke, here's
Valenti denounces file-sharing, by Alex Garinger, The Chronicle (Duke U).
[Jack] Valenti, president and chief executive officer of the Motion Picture Association of America, called upon universities to develop a code of conduct for their Internet-using students and argued for a moral imperative to stop file-swapping during the third annual Meredith and Kip Frey Lecture in Intellectual Property at the School of Law Monday.
. . .
The newspaper is full of sordid stories of the unbounded avarice of a lot of corporate executives, Valenti said. These executives knew they were cheating and stealing from their employees and stockholders.... [File-downloaders] are doing the same thing.
. . .
Law students in attendance engaged in a lively debate with Valenti following his lecture, posing pointed questions and attempting to find possible loopholes in the illegality of copying digital material. Valenti remained stalwart in opposition to file-downloading.
He says a lot of funny things, but he is pretty obnoxious and sort of a one-note Johnny, said second-year law student Kimberly Klimczuk after the event. When someone brings up a legitimate concern, he goes off on a rant as to why it is stealing.
I refer Mr. Valenti to my earlier remarks about the ethics of the industry he represents. Plagiarism and phony accounting certainly make this a pot-kettle situation at best. But since the story is not so simple as "download=theft," even that bit of (im)moral equivalence falls short.
9:42:18 AM
|
|
|