Comix
Musings on funnybooks

CATEGORIES









FAVORITE SITES







BLOGS I LIKE














Subscribe to "Comix" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.
 

 

Thursday, August 29, 2002
 

Report from San Diego Comic Con 2002

Seattle, August 5, 2002. So we just got back from Comic-Con International: San Diego. I anticipate a full week of recovery time. The Con is not only a full-on assault on the senses, it’s also pretty physically demanding just getting from place to place on the enormous convention floor. I haven’t found any official attendance numbers yet, but I would not be surprised by any estimate up to 90,000. It was (in my best South Park "Tweak" voice) INSANE! The exhibitor area was a half-mile end-to-end, carved into over sixty aisles of booths featuring comics, toys, manga and anime stuff (lots of that), movie tie-ins, artwork and artists, animation stuff, books, memorabilia and more. Almost every booth had something to grab you, whether it was a wall of $1 million worth of vintage comics that no collector has ever seen in person, or celebrities ranging from Peter "Chewbacca" Mayhew to animator Bill Plympton to the latest Playmate of the Month dressed as Sailor Moon and handing out free hologram key-chains. Many attendees come in costume. There were enough stormtroopers to staff a complete clone army; Klingons in full battle regalia, swinging Bat’leths to clear a path for themselves through the aisles; all sorts of Elves, Hobbits and wizards, muppets, samurai, Roswell aliens, etc. It may sound wacky, but in context it makes perfect sense.

Upstairs – for those who made it that far – were panel discussions on every subject you can imagine, sneak previews of movies featuring unannounced surprise appearances by cast members, gaming tournaments, Japanese anime running round the clock on three screens, a complete Star Wars fan film festival, slide shows on classic SF paperback cover artwork, and even a live edition of the Comedy Central kitch game show "Beat the Geeks" (the official corporate Geeks lost, badly – they were no match for the real thing). The main programming went from 10-7 each day, but then at night were the various awards ceremonies, parties, costume contests, film marathons, club meetings, dinners and general mayhem.

My consort and co-conspirator Eunice and I arrived on Wednesday, early enough to squeeze in a few hours of traditional "recreation" (hanging around the pool, stuff like that) before the festivities got underway. The Con has begun featuring a "preview night" from 5-8:30 so that full four-day attendees could register and have a look at the goods without having to cue up in annoying crowd-control pens on Thursday morning. Last year it was pretty makeshift – most exhibitors were still setting up, no artists or guests bothered to attend. This year there were 9,500 people and everything was in full swing. Three and a half hours was barely enough time to walk half the convention floor, even with the aisles mostly clear. There was a profound sense of awe in the room about the size and scale that this thing had reached.

On Thursday – usually a light day for attendance – the place was nearly full. Most people do their serious shopping on Thursday to beat the weekend rush and get to the dealers before prices go up. If you ever go, bring about double the amount of money you think you’ll spend. There is more STUFF here than you can possibly imagine. 1979 Boba Fett original figure, new in box? Someone’s got it. Uncut sheet of Wacky Pack trading cards from 1974? Someone’s got it. Original cover art to Amazing Spider-Man #49 from 1966? Someone’s got it (for a bargain price of only $22K!). "Federal Men," the ridiculously obscure 1946 one-shot reprint of old Siegel and Shuster pre-Superman strips? Yup, someone was selling it and I actually bought it (well come on, when was I ever going to see another one?). Somewhere underneath of a twenty-foot pile of empty containers from the neighboring booth, we found our friends Peter and Carolyn Bickford taking orders for the new edition of ComicBase – my single very slim writing credit in the comic business. Yes indeed, there’s something for every obsessive collector under the sun, all in one gargantuan room.

Eunice is a member of a group called Friends of Lulu, dedicated to increasing the presence of women in comics. Thursday night was their annual party and awards dinner, hosted in a nice ballroom on the top floor of a nearby hotel. FOL is a great place to rub elbows with many of the coolest people in the business. It’s also one party I would not miss if I were single. Afterwards we went out for a few drinks in the hip "Gaslamp District" of San Diego with my old friend from high school Steve Stein, who was also in for the Con. One of the cool things about the Big Weekend is that the city of San Diego is overrun with freaks, geeks and comic book crazies. Toe-headed southern California jocks and their bubble-blond girlfriends are shocked and horrified to discover that their favorite hang-outs are suddenly full of unwashed lunatics arguing Star Trek trivia and playing Magic cards at the bar.

On Friday, we attended a panel discussion that was supposed to feature Stan Lee being interviewed by Kevin Smith. Unfortunately, Smith (a Con regular the last few years) couldn’t make it, so Stan the Man put up with inane questions from a panel of clueless assholes. Still, Stan Lee is always worth seeing, and this is probably not the first time he’s been publicly questioned by idiots.

That night was the Eisner Awards – the comic book equivalent of the Oscars – where the entire industry turns out to honor the best work of the year. Like the Oscars, the ceremony takes forever because there are awards for EVERYTHING, everyone needs to be introduced, all the nominees get applause, and then the winners all thank everyone. Unlike the Oscars, the man that the Eisner awards are named for – comic book pioneer and genius Will Eisner – is still very much alive and present to hand out the awards. He even won one himself this year. Well sure – can you imagine losing an award named after yourself? Or, as a judge, voting for anyone other than Will Eisner to win an Eisner award in a category where he’s been nominated? The event is usually followed by a party, but we were so tired that we went straight back to the hotel.

On Saturday morning while we were having breakfast in our hotel room, we saw the line forming to get into the convention center. The registration area for the Con is on the second floor, up a gigantic escalator at the end of a Disneyland-style serpentine rope line. In earlier years, the line on a busy day would extend outside and partway down the length of the convention center – a wait of approximately 45 minutes. Saturday morning, the line went the full length of the convention center, around the side, past the hotel adjacent to it, and all the way down the seaside boardwalk to the shopping center past our hotel – a distance of more than 1.5 miles. This was at 8:00 am, two hours before the doors opened. Eunice and I already had our badges, so we just need to wait until 10:15 and walk right in, but apparently some people were still getting their credentials at 1:00 in the afternoon. God help anyone who tried to park or drive anywhere within five miles of downtown SD.

Inside, insanity reigned. Guest celebrities were everywhere, everyone was in costumes, kids were screaming, music was blasting, dealers were keeping customers at bay with chairs and bullwhips, several popular artists were torn to pieces and their flayed skin was sold as souvenirs (highly collectable!) by enterprising merchants. We attended a series of panels upstairs, where the mayhem was at a slightly lower decibel level.

First we went to a discussion of the work of Steve Ditko, co-creator of Spider-Man, featuring several of his colleagues. Next was an interview of SF great Ray Bradbury by his longtime friend and one-time literary agent Julius Schwartz, a legendary editor at DC comics. Al Feldstein, the editor who "adapted" Bradbury’s stories in EC comics (initially without Bradbury’s permission) made a surprise appearance at which he dissolved into an utter puddle of fanboy admiration and tearfully thanked Uncle Ray for providing him with the inspiration to do his best work. It was a great moment to anyone with an interest in the history of science fiction, this was itself worth the price of admission. After that wrapped up, we stuck around to hear Buffy the Vampire Slayer creator Joss Whedon discuss his upcoming new series (sorry, title escapes me for the moment, but it looks cool) and answer questions about new developments on Buffy and Angel. Joss looked a little ragged – probably because they had to smuggle him into the convention in a burlap bag for his own protection. We left when the questions became too embarrassingly fannish even for us.

Down on the floor at 4:30, it was impossible to move. The aisles were packed. There’s a rumor that the fire marshal was close to shutting the whole thing down – one of the largest enclosed spaces on earth, filled to capacity! Forget about subculture. We have arrived. We are everywhere!

Saturday night, Eunice and I attended a dinner hosted by a group called the American Association of Comic Collectors, which honors some of the old-timers who made it in for the convention. The dinner is a small affair – about 75 people – so there’s lots of opportunities to talk directly with the guests and the other attendees (many of whom are current artists, high-profile collectors and dealers). Remember that in the 40s and 50s, no one gave a shit about comics and it was something of an embarrassment to be involved in the industry. Many of the artists from those days still don’t realize that there are people who remember and appreciate their work, and every year, a few more are "discovered" by dedicated collectors and invited to attend Comic-Con as guests of honor. Most of these people are now over 70, living modest lives, and are suddenly plunged into this sea of mayhem and thronged by literally hundreds of people who praise their work, thank them for their efforts, present them with treasured copies of old issues, and ask for autographs and sketches. It must be quite an experience. Eunice and I sat at a table with a wonderful old fellow named Lew Sayre Schwartz, who had one of the most thankless jobs in comics history – ghost-drawing Batman stories in the fifties under the moniker of creator Bob Kane. After that, he left comics behind for a prosperous but anonymous career in commercial art and was genuinely shocked to discover that here, half a century later, he was being celebrated for work that he was sure no one but Kane had ever known he had done. To say that he and his wife were delighted would be something of an understatement. It’s pretty uplifting to share someone’s moment of happiness like that. After that was the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund party and more late-night partying and drinking with lots of cool people.

Sunday is a blur – a mad scramble to fill the last few holes in my collection and pick up a few more sketches from various artists. By mid-day, everyone – dealers, guests, attendees – is totally burned out. Brain-dead zombies shamble around the aisles. Pathetic once-human husks are draped lifelessly over folding chairs with eyes rolled back and drool trickling from their slack open mouths. Artists collapse suddenly at their tables, tumbling face first into half-inked pages on their drawing boards. Dealers, desperate to unload inventory, climb up onto tables and rasp out announcements of sales from ruined throats, or scratch ever-deeper discount notices onto chalk-stained blackboards. Oh, the humanity!

At 4:15, with a full 45 minutes to go before closing, we finally hit the wall. Realizing that we haven’t eaten in four days, we kick in the door of a nearby Mexican restaurant and fall on the terrified staff like half-mad animals. Outside, the waves of refugees begin to fill the streets. Imagine some newsreel of a flood in Bangladesh, except everyone is wearing t-shirts with Spider-Man insignias or X-Men, carrying poster tubes, and pulling luggage trolleys piled high with comic books and toys. Those lucky enough to have plane tickets make for the airports. Others lash their belongings to the tops of old jalopies or pack animals and join the long, slow procession up I-405. A few unfortunates perch on rooftops and make desperate leaps for the landing skids of circling traffic helicopters. When the Con is over, it is Time to Leave San Diego, make no mistake.

That’s the good thing about the Con. They give you a large enough portion that by the time it’s over, you don’t need to go back for at least six months. Then the Hunger sets in.. .the gnawing anticipation… the feverish longing… the horrible fear that the next con can’t possibly live up to last year’s… Oh God… how much longer do I have to wait? Fortunately, we are already registered for 2003. Eunice took care of that on Thursday morning.


12:43:56 PM    Emphasize This! []

No Sense of Humor About Comics in Texas

Comic books have been with us since at least the 1930s, and for a long time they were considered, in the words of one old-time comic editor, "reading matter for children of below-average intelligence." In the 50s, a psychologist named Frederic Wertham suggested that gruesome and violent comics were a key cause of juvenile deliquency - a charge that captured the imagination of a paranoid and hysterical populace during the height of the McCarthy era. The resulting fallout nearly killed the industry, and certainly inhibited the development of the artform as a medium for expression of sophisticated ideas.

In the 60s, underground comix emerged as part of the overall counter-culture movement and provided a roadmap for ambitious creators to explore issues like sex and politics using a widely-accessible graphic medium and a DIY distribution system. Those tendencies - including the proclivity of some creators to push the limits of expression (sometimes without regard to taste or quality) - have since become, if not mainstream, then certainly a familiar and accepted part of the comic art vocabulary, and many titles on the shelves cater to adults.

Nevertheless, some pinheads still insist that comics are a medium that is, or should be, exclusively targeted at kids, and moreover, that "bad comics" have the mysterious power to cloud kids' minds and tempt them into EVIL! This would be funny except that said pinheads control the law-enforcement aparatus in many parts of the country, including, shockingly, that bastion of enlightenment we know as Texas. And. in their never-ending battle for truth, justice and the American Way, they have turned their wrath on the owner of a Dallas comic store, who now faces a not-so-funny six month sentence for the crime of selling adult-oriented material... to adults!

This account courtesy of the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund:

Store Manager Sentenced to Six Months in Jail - CBLDF Appeals Retailer Conviction

August 14, 2002. The lawyer for the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund (CBLDF) has filed an appeal to the highest criminal court in Texas in the obscenity conviction of Jesus Castillo, manager of a Dallas comic store. Castillo was convicted by a jury in August 2000 of "display of obscenity" for selling Demon Beast Invasion #2 to an adult. He was sentenced to 180 days in jail, a year's probation, and a $4,000 fine.

This second appeal, a Petition for Discretionary Review, is being made after the Fifth District Court of Appeals upheld Castillo's conviction in July in a 2-1 decision. The dissenter, Justice Tom James, agreed with the majority that the comic was obscene, but felt that it was not clear that Castillo knew what the content was.

The original conviction was surprising. The store in question handled its adult materials carefully, with three display areas: its general display area, an 18 and up section in the back of the store, and explicit adult materials kept in a box behind the counter. Store employees also required proof of age before selling adult materials to younger customers. But in its closing arguments, the prosecution used the store's proximity to a school and the comic format to argue that the product was designed to appeal to children. Here's an excerpt from that closing argument:

"And, again, why are we here? ... This medium, the medium that this obscenity is placed in is done so in an appealing manner to children. Comic books, and I don't care what type of evidence or what type of testimony is out there, use your rationality, use your common sense. Comic books, traditionally what we think of, are for kids. This is in a store directly across from an elementary school and it is put in a medium, in a forum, to directly appeal to kids. That is why we are here, ladies and gentlemen. I want to re-emphasize that the fact that all this smut is out there, does not mean it's acceptable and is decent by our community. We're here to get this off the shelf."

The jury rejected expert testimony from Scott McCloud and Susan Napier, who addressed the work's literary, cultural, and artistic merit. A second charge, for selling Legend of the Overfiend to an adult, was dropped after the conviction on the first.

If the conviction cannot be overturned, the consequences for the store manager are going to be severe -- the loss of his freedom for six months and a criminal record for handling a constitutionally protected publication in a responsible way. It's ironic that just as the nation's most respected publications are talking about the way comics are addressing serious issues (see "New York Times Covers Green Lantern #154 "), a retailer is fighting to keep from going to jail for selling an adult comic to an adult.

The CBLDF has already spent $40,000 defending Castillo, and a long battle may still be ahead. A call is going out for urgently needed donations to support the Fund's work. Donations can be made by clicking here (just put a "10"in the $50 box).


10:26:08 AM    Emphasize This! []


Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website. © Copyright 2003 Rob Salkowitz.
Last update: 2/17/2003; 12:03:26 PM.
This theme is based on the SoundWaves (blue) Manila theme.
August 2002
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Jul   Sep