Kofi Annan used the word "Illegal" about Iraq war
UN General Secretary Kofi Annan created headlines and got an enthusiastic response from war opponents today when he allowed the word "illegal" to be dragged out of him by the BBC's clever interviewer Owen Bennett-Jones.
Q: I wanted to ask you that - do you think that the resolution that was passed on Iraq before the war did actually give legal authority to do what was done?
A: Well, I'm one of those who believe that there should have been a second resolution because the Security Council indicated that if Iraq did not comply there will be consequences. But then it was up to the Security Council to approve or determine what those consequences should be.
Q: So you don't think there was legal authority for the war?
A: I have stated clearly that it was not in conformity with the Security Council - with the UN Charter.
Q: It was illegal?
A: Yes, if you wish.
Q: It was illegal?
A: Yes, I have indicated it is not in conformity with the UN Charter, from our point of view and from the Charter point of view it was illegal.
The statement has inspired some heated debate today, along the usual fault lines. Kofi Annan has expressed the exact same sentiment earlier, using different words, but knew just too well how important it was to avoid saying "illegal" if he didn't want to open up old wounds.
This is demonstrated when the interviewer asks him whether the atrocities in Darfur in Sudan can be called a 'genocide.'
Q: The US Secretary of State, Colin Powell, has said that what's going on in Sudan is genocide, do you agree with him?
A:...I've talked about the atrocious and systematic and grave... gross violations of human rights and violations of international humanitarian law...
There he is getting evasive and avoids saying anything that would commit the Secretary General's office to actually do anything to stop the murders, rapes and the horrible refugee situation in Darfur.
Kofi Annan knew just too well that calling the war "illegal" would encourage the anti-democratic elements in Iraq and their explicit supporters abroad as well as the useful fools who hopes a total failure in Iraq will put the Americans in their places. His choice of words shows what outcome he would like to see.
7:53:53 PM
|