Jon Husband has picked up an interesting concept from Evelyn Rodriguez and Matthew Dallman: that blogging could be considered a form of performance art.
This has a kind of ego-stroking visceral appeal to bloggers (it sure
beats the mainstream media depiction of bloggers as 'a million guys in
pajamas'). But does 'performance art' actually describe what we do?
Go
through the history of the terms 'performance art' and 'performing
arts' and you'll quickly end up in a quagmire: There is no consensus on
what these terms mean and what they include and exclude. So let's go
back to the roots and discover what the words originally meant:
perform = to give what is needed through some means or vehicle
art = an imitation or reflection of nature, life or reality
The
first definition explains why we use the term 'perform surgery' – a
performance can as easily be scientific or religious ('perform a
ritual') as artistic. The only requirements for performance are that
the actions fill a need and that they do so in an intermediated way,
through the body or some other 'medium'. And that need can be a
personal one rather than one for an audience: one might even wryly
describe masturbation as 'solo performance art'.
By these
criteria blogging certainly qualifies as performance, even more than
most less-interactive forms of journalism. And there is no question
that all forms of writing qualify as art by the second definition. So
blogging is a form of
performance or performing art. Arguably, as Evelyn points out, so is
participation in World of Warcraft or Second Life. Even masks,
piercings, clothing, and body painting meet the above definitions of
performance art.
What does it mean to say that blogging is a performance, or performing, art form?
Most performance/performing art is narrative:
Blogs, like most music, films, interactive writing, and for that matter
most theatre, often tell or retell (artistically) stories. I have
argued that blogging is a form of conversation, with unequal roles for,
but a tacit contract with, the audience, the other participants in the performance.
But
"theatre isn't about narrative, narrative isn't necessary", quotes
Evelyn. So performance art need not be narrative, provided it meets a
need. She argues that performance art should be participatory – it needs to engage the intellect, the emotions, and/or the senses – and blogging can do that.
Matthew
Dallman goes further, arguing that blogging is "a vehicle for the
emergence of informed intuition". Between these two definitions, the
four Jungian forms of knowledge and learning are represented:
intellectual, emotional, sensory and intuitive. And I've argued before
that good presentations (another form of narrative performance art) can
be either informative or entertaining. So it seems as if the 'what is
needed' that is provided by performance art can be either (a) the
acquisition of knowledge or appreciation, or (b) diversion or pleasure.
In so doing it does not have to be either narrative or participatory.
In
that respect, blogging is no different from any other performance art:
What fills person A's needs may not do it for person B, and vice versa.
Its 'success' at filling a need is a function of the needs, openness
and capacity of the audience to get value from the presentation: How
ready, willing and able they are to appreciate the performance's
message.
I would argue that the greater the participation of the
audience (even to the point the roles of performer and audience get
blurred), the more receptive the audience becomes to the performance's
meaning and value. For example, a good novel will get the reader caught
up in the story to the point that s/he becomes a participant in it –
and imagines himself or herself there. Except when they too tell stories, this is very hard to do in blogging.
Fortunately
for bloggers who aren't good at storytelling, there are simpler ways
for a performance to succeed. Give me a useful take-away that I can
relate to my own experiences, and you've succeeded in giving me what I
need, and I'll applaud the performance. Example: In Evelyn's bio she
quotes Goethe:
If you must tell me your opinions, tell me what you believe in. I have plenty of doubts of my own.
This is brilliant
advice for bloggers, in one terse sentence. By including it prominently
in her blog, Evelyn shows herself to be an accomplished performance
artist. That may have something to do with the fact that Goethe was a
genius. Or it may have something to do with the fact that I am 'ready'
for this message, that it resonates with my worldview and that it meets
a need of the moment. Why she succeeds doesn't matter. As bloggers, our job is simply to perform, to practice our art in public. Any applause is just a bonus.
|
MADE IN CANADA
trust your
instincts 
