
In the latest (May-June) edition of Orion, Chris Cokinos
writes about the
unbearable grief for Gaia that so many of us feel, relentlessly. In a similar vein to Richard Bruce Anderson's
article,
its goal is to help us get past the first three stages of grief
(denial, anger and despair) to the fourth and final stage (acceptance).
"Sometimes I feel that I'm supposed to save the entire biosphere",
Cokinos writes. "Sometimes I just hang my head in exhaustion and
doubt...[But] too much grief for the world means less energy to help it
along...I do what I can without going crazy...Of course it is never
enough...Here's what I know: I know that when you find yourself free of
the poisons that too much angst can cultivate, then something marvelous
happens...you can keep going on, you can keep doing the work you do in
this universe, feeling despair, feeling -- amazing -- joy when you feel
joy." He admits it's "hard to say" how to "find yourself free" to do
"this right work that is calm" and achieve "this letting-go and
holding-on all at once".
He tries to give us some perspective on how we might do this by
invoking the stories of the previous five great extinction events, and
reminding us that over 99% of the species that have existed on this
planet are now extinct, and that within a billion years, as our sun
begins to go nova, any life on this planet will be burned up anyway.
Somehow this is small consolation, and sounds at times more an attempt
to help us inure ourselves (inure means "to habituate to something
undesirable, especially by prolonged subjection") than to help us come
to accept and understand what we're doing and what we can, and must,
do, to "find ourselves free".
When I discovered Anderson's article on Dave Smith's site, I found
it illuminating and, to some extent, consoling. I said then that I
thought I was stuck at the third stage of grief (despair). Knowing your
problem, they say, is half way to solving it. And since then I have become a happier person, more knowledgeable of what I
can and cannot do to make the world better. But not, I believe, any
less grief-stricken. I have not yet "found myself free".
I suspect I am in good company in this. Someone asked me, in an
interview a while ago, where I thought the world stood in understanding
what we have done and are doing and what needs to be done. I replied
that most are unaware, not out of ignorance but because they're too
busy dealing with the needs of the moment. Instinctively they know there is something wrong, but they
haven't the time or immediate inclination to figure out what it is.
Perhaps there is a 'pre-denial' stage of grief where we're only vaguely
aware of impending tragedy, an ominous feeling of foreboding but
nothing more. Perhaps six of the 6.5 billion people on the planet are
at that stage.
Then there are those of us, the other half-billion, who have had either
the good fortune of time, opportunity and resources to have come to grips
with the utter tragedy and unsustainability of our civilization, or the good
fortune to have lived largely outside of it and been able to see it for
what it is all along, from the Edge. Our grief is more informed, and,
like those drawn to a train-wreck, once we start to learn we strive to
learn more, to understand why and what can be done, until we pass that
threshhold that I call the point of unbearability and start to turn
away, the point where more knowledge just deepens the grief and no
longer informs or motivates us, no longer moves us to action.
That point varies, of course, with our circumstances. Mostly, it
depends on how beholden we are to our civilization, how drawn by the
great gravitational force always luring us away from the Edge to the
seductive Centre, with its promise of wealth, fame, popularity,
security (for us and our loved ones), creature comfort, excitement,
distraction. The more attuned we are to our instincts, the more we will
refuse to be seduced, and the closer we will come to the Edge. The
motley crew closer to the Edge have the capacity to feel that grief
more acutely, and it is this group that Anderson and Cokinos are
addressing (and it is this group for whom I write, mainly, on this
blog).
There have been moments when I have, briefly, "found myself free",
or at least relatively so. Moments of intoxicating love, of sudden
understanding, of peace, of discovery, of awareness. The problem is
that they are fleeting, and unsustainable, as the noise of the
machine in our heads,
and the realization of just how terrible this world is, rush back into
our consciousness. We keep hoping for transcendence, and there are many
self-proclaimed gurus and sellers of distracting and addictive
products who will tell us how to achieve it, how to get past the grief
forever and still be real rather than 'comfortably disconnected' as
I described in yesterday's poem.
Our austere, puritan, victorian, utilitarian culture teaches us
that life is hard and we are sinful, and that moments of happiness are
rare and incidental to our purpose. So perhaps we come too easily to
accept that these brief respites from grief, these moments of freedom,
are the best we can hope for.
I suppose it depends on how close to the Edge we can stay, and
what we do with our lives, and the stuff we are made of. I've been
unbelievably fortunate to be able to move, relatively easily, closer to
the Edge as I've grown older. That's just dumb luck, but it's given me
some financial independence and flexibility that few ever realize. I
have also been blessed with few obligations or burdens. And I know what
I'm going to do with the rest of my life, I've figured out how to
Let-Self-Change and what I'm meant to do. Those less fortunate or less
self-assured than I am can be excused for turning away from their grief
and its cause, and doing what they must to stay sane and to look after
the people they love who need them.
I have no such excuse, and I cannot,
will not
turn away. Grief is in our nature, because it is our reaction to the
loss of love, the love that bonds us and makes us one with
all-life-on-Earth, a consequence of our propensity to remember what is
important (read
When Elephants Weep
if you want to understand this better), and our natural reaction to
great and enduring stress. I'll carry that weight, not because I'm
brave or courageous or exemplary, but because I can, and must. I'm sure
I'll be in good company, a small but insufficient army of people trying
to make the world a better place, "letting-go and holding-on all at
once", only occasionally "finding ourselves free", but honoured to be
able to do what we can to help. Crazy, perhaps, crazy in love with this
wondrous, scarred, sacred, ruined, magical world.
Onward.