Dave Pollard's papers on business innovation & knowledge management



August 2005
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      
Jul   Sep


leafMADE IN CANADA

leaf trust your instincts



< £ Salon Bloggers & >





Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.

 


 

  August 19, 2005


prison2Alex Pattakos' book Prisoners of our Thoughts synthesizes the work of death camp survivor Viktor Frankl down to seven key principles that will help you be happier and more successful in your life:
  1. Exercise the freedom to choose your own attitude
  2. Know your "why", and discover your higher purpose
  3. Overcome your fears through self-knowledge
  4. Don't try too hard or delude yourself, so you don't work against your self-interest
  5. See yourself from a distance, so you 'get outside yourself'
  6. Shift your 'frame', your focus of attention, so you can see things differently
  7. Get beyond your own self-interest, and connect with community and the world
It's hard to argue with these principles, but I have the same problem with these that I do with the whole mountain of 'self-help' books out there. I don't believe that people fundamentally change (although if they go through what Frankl did, which I can't imagine doing, maybe they could). For the rest of us, I feel about these make-yourself-better programs much the way I feel about 'beauty' products: They make us feel we aren't good enough as we are, and create expectations of becoming a better (or better-looking) person, expectations that are almost certain to be dashed. So we either get addicted, signing up for more self-improvement in the futile hope that with enough work we will finally get there and become (spiritually or intellectually or physically) beautiful (when by implication we aren't now), or we get disillusioned, and our self-esteem suffers lasting damage.

We are who we are. We are not prisoners of our thoughts, I think, so much as prisoners of our bodies and our genes. What we can affect, much more than who we are, perhaps, is what we do with our lives. By learning about the real world, and taking responsibility and acting on that learning, I believe, we are more likely to change who we are, and make the world better in the process, than we would by introspection of the type suggested by self-help authors. That's not to say we needn't change ourselves before we try to change others (and the world) -- just that that self-change will come first from our actions in the world, not from self-analysis and reading.

In a complicated universe, it makes sense (as Snowden says) to analyze before you act. But in a complex universe (which I think the one we all live in really is) analysis is futile -- you probe, outside yourself, before you act. When I visit the bookstore, you'll usually find me in the cultural studies, fiction, history, poetry, politics, economics, humour, nature, science, philosophy and business innovation sections. The self-help section is huge and busy, but I usually give it a wide berth.

Am I being unfair here? Is there something in all these million-seller self-help books that I'm missing? Can reading a story about moving cheese really save your career, your marriage and your life?

7:16:55 PM  trackback []  comment []


Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website. © Copyright 2005 Dave Pollard.
Last update: 02/09/2005; 12:56:52 PM.



SEARCH SITE
How to Save the World



leaf THINKING OF MOVING TO CANADA?
(immigration info blog)


Technorati Cosmos


Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Subscribe to this blog by
Add to My Yahoo!

.
.
.
.
.


Subscribe to "Business Innovation" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.





WHAT THE BLOGOSPHERE WANTS MORE OF

Blog readers want to see more:
  1. original research, surveys etc.
  2. original, well-crafted fiction
  3. great finds: resources, blogs, essays, artistic works
  4. news not found anywhere else
  5. category killers: aggregators that capture the best of many blogs/feeds, so they need not be read individually
  6. clever, concise political opinion (most readers prefer these consistent with their own views)
  7. benchmarks, quantitative analysis
  8. personal stories, experiences, lessons learned
  9. first-hand accounts
  10. live reports from events
  11. insight: leading-edge thinking & novel perspectives
  12. short educational pieces
  13. relevant "aha" graphics
  14. great photos
  15. useful tools and checklists
  16. précis, summaries, reviews and other time-savers
  17. fun stuff: quizzes, self-evaluations, other interactive content

Blog writers want to see more:
  1. constructive criticism, reaction, feedback
  2. 'thank you' comments, and why readers liked their post
  3. requests for future posts on specific subjects
  4. foundation articles: posts that writers can build on, on their own blogs
  5. reading lists/aggregations of material on specific, leading-edge subjects that writers can use as resource material
  6. wonderful examples of writing of a particular genre, that they can learn from
  7. comments that engender lively discussion
  8. guidance on how to write in the strange world of weblogs


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.