Israeli Civil War?

Kill them all! says Rabbi Neventzal
The Orthodox Rabbi of old Jerusalem told Israeli radio that anyone intending to give over parts of Israeli land falls under the halachic category of din rodef - someone who endangers life - and thus can be killed if necessary in order to stop him.
"The nation is divided into two, and each side sees the other as persecutor. As long as the government's laws don't contradict the laws of the Torah, then those laws are legitimate. But if those laws go against the Torah, then they are not legitimate. Din Rodef is issued against anyone who endangers Jews," Neventzal said on Israel Radio.
"If I have to stand trial for what I said, I have no problem with that," Neventzal added
He should stand trial, That kind of rhetoric is exactly what led to the assassination of Yitzak Rabin in 1995. Jews killing Jews is expressly forbidden in the Torah and in rabbinical teachings.
This kind of thing highlights an issue that affects diasporah Jews far more than those in Israel. The issue is the Orthodox control of religious ministries and schools in Israel. If you're married in the United States, or any other country for that matter, by a rabbi who is ANYTHING other than Orthodox, then if you immigrate to Israel you have to get re-married in an Orthodox ceremony in order to be considered married by the State of Israel!
The same goes for virtually every other area of Jewish religious life, the Orthodox control it. They get money for their schools and the students of the Yeshivas are exempt from military service! So basically they get to sit around on their asses all day studying the Torah, sucking off the tit of the government, and everyone else pays for it, and they can completely avoid military service in the Israeli Defense Forces through a religious exemption.
I've no issue with the Orthodox, they can remain true to their brand of Judaism as long as they want, it's not my business. But I do have an issue with them controlling all aspects of religious life in Israel as well as some of them using dangerous rhetoric like the rabbi above.
The vast majority of Jews in the United States are non-Orthodox Jews. We're the largest community of Jews in the world, including Israel, and we have to sit and be dictated to by these black-hat wearing extremists? I don't think so.
12:08:34 PM
|