White House Press Simulacrum

British philosopher, mathematician and computer scientist Alan Turing conceived of a test to determine whether computers were intelligent -- the so-called "Turing Test":
[A] human being and a computer would be interrogated under conditions where the interrogator would not know which was which, the communication being entirely by textual messages. Turing argued that if the interrogator could not distinguish them by questioning, then it would be unreasonable not to call the computer intelligent.
The one possibility Turing didn't consider (so far as I know) is that computers might one day converse more convincingly than human beings.
Take White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan, for instance. Is there any doubt that he would consistently fail the test?
Not for anyone who has read a transcript from a White House Press Conference, Briefing, or Gaggle. See the choice excerpts Josh Marshall picks out (here, here, and here).
Better yet, is there any doubt that Bush would consistently fail the test?
Isn't it about time we raised productivity and cut costs at the White House by replacing the Press Secretary and his staff with an automated system?
"For the President's view on marriage, press one ..."
[1]
"The President has always firmly believed that marriage is a sacred institution between a man and a woman. He supports efforts to protect and defend the sanctity of marriage."
"If you wish to repeat this message, press one. To return to the main menu, press pound ..."
And how about doing the same with the President and his staff? How about a computer-simulated President? We could outsource the work to the best computer companies in India and China. Indian cinema is also booming -- an excellent source of cheap PR contractors. I'm sure they'd charge less than the ex-Fox people they use nowadays.
Postscript: Several of Dick's works played on this idea. For example, in The Simulacra, the President, unbenounced to the
American public, is an android, and the country is actually run by the beloved, glamorous First Lady, Nancy Thibideaux (playing on the popular appeal of Jacqueline Kennedy).
1:44:00 AM
|